Thursday, 7 March 2013

Intensity of Light - Higher and Lower Sensitivity (4.1b)


Requirement
At least 12 images, 6 scenes x High/Low ISO

Purpose
  • To understand the trade-off  in low light of using either low or high ISO: desired exposure vs. higher levels of noise

Technical Learning
  • Most cameras are designed so that they can capture sharply at ISO 100 people walking in average daylight, when handheld (shutter speed of at least 1/125 sec) using an aperture producing acceptable depth of field (say, f5.6)
  • As light reduces from this level, some adjustment is needed (i.e. ISO, shutter speed or aperture)
  • Increasing ISO, say from 100 to 400, is an EV4.0 change, enabling either shutter speed to be 4 times faster (reducing motion blur) or aperture to be 4 times narrower (lengthening depth of field), or some combination of both
  • However, the price for using higher ISO is the increased risk of noise
Noise
  • It is a sampling error where less than an ideal level of light reaches the sensor producing a random pattern of aberrant pixels, typically of varying brightness (luminance) and colour (chrominance)
  • It is usually most evident in areas of continuous tone and deep shadow
  • Its impact depends on the size at which the image is viewed, i.e. the larger the more noticeable it becomes
  • It is the opposite of 2 other effects: 'blooming' (flare around blown highlights) and chromatic aberration (highlights with either a red-cyan or blue-yellow fringe)

Exercise Instructions
  • Shoot 6 scenes first at ISO 400/800 where motion and/or depth of field may be at the margin of acceptability, then shoot the same scene at ISO 100. What impact did the higher ISO setting have?
  • Examine areas of flat tone and deep shadow in each image for signs of noise in close-up
  • Consider to what extent noise matters in these images

Images and Review

Used the spinning wheel of my wife's bicycle in the dimly lit garage to conduct this test.


Lumix DMC G3

ISO 100
Shutter Speed = 2.5 seconds
ISO 100 - Magnified
Low Noise

ISO 6400
Shutter speed = 1/15 second
ISO 6400 Magnified
High noise

Nikon D 200
ISO 3200
Shutter speed = 1/30
Low light, high ISO performance comparable
to Lumix, perhaps worse given
D 200's max ISO of 3200

Nikon D 700
ISO 6400
Shutter speed = 1/45
Significant improvement in sensor performance

Nikon D 800

ISO 25600
Shutter speed = 1/160 second
Another dimension of improvement in quality

No comments:

Post a Comment